Why Talking About Trauma Isn't Always Enough

Have you ever found yourself saying "I've talked about it so many times. I understand why I feel this way. So why does it still affect me?"

Perhaps you've spent time in therapy exploring your childhood, making sense of difficult relationships or talking through something frightening that happened to you. You understand how your experiences have shaped you. You can explain why certain situations make you anxious, why you struggle to trust people or why you find it difficult to relax. And yet, despite all that understanding, something hasn't quite shifted. You still feel the same fear, shame or panic. Perhaps you still find yourself reacting to things in ways that don't seem to make sense, even when you know you're safe. If this sounds familiar, I want you to know that it doesn't mean you've failed at therapy, that you've been doing it wrong or that you're somehow beyond help.

Sometimes understanding what happened to you and processing what happened to you are two different things. This is where EMDR, can be helpful.

Talking about trauma can be incredibly valuable

Before exploring why talking isn't always enough, it's important to say that talking therapy can be enormously helpful.

Having someone listen to you, help you make sense of your experiences and understand your reactions can be an important part of recovery. It can help you recognise patterns, develop healthier ways of relating to yourself and others, and begin to understand how your past influences your present. For some people, talking through difficult experiences is exactly what they need.

But for others, particularly those experiencing PTSD or the ongoing effects of trauma, talking alone doesn't always bring the changes they're hoping for.

  • You might understand perfectly well that your childhood wasn't your fault.
  • You might know that your previous relationship was emotionally abusive.
  • You might recognise that your birth experience was frightening and that you weren't responsible for what happened.

But knowing these things doesn't necessarily mean you feel them. And that distinction matters.

‍

Why do traumatic experiences continue to affect us?

When something frightening or overwhelming happens, our brain and body respond in ways designed to protect us.

Our attention becomes focused on detecting danger. We might experience intense fear, helplessness, panic or a sense that we have no control over what's happening. Sometimes, the memory of that experience doesn't become fully integrated with our other memories. Instead, aspects of it can remain particularly vivid and distressing.

You might find yourself reacting to reminders of what happened through:

  • Intrusive memories or flashbacks.
  • Physical sensations such as a racing heart or feeling sick.
  • Intense feelings of fear, shame or helplessness.
  • Avoiding particular places, people or situations.
  • Feeling constantly on guard.
  • Beliefs about yourself, such as "I'm not safe", "I'm powerless" or "I'm not good enough".

These reactions can continue long after the original experience has ended. This is one reason why someone can intellectually know that something is over but still experience intense emotional and physical reactions when reminded of it.

Your thinking brain knows you're safe. But something about the experience still feels unresolved.

"I know it wasn't my fault, but I still feel ashamed"

This is something I think many people who have experienced trauma will recognise. You might know that you weren't responsible for what happened. You might have had this explained to you countless times. Your therapist might have helped you understand that you were a child, that you had no control over the situation or that you did the best you could under incredibly difficult circumstances.

And yet, the shame remains.Perhaps you still feel somehow responsible. Perhaps you still believe you should have done something differently. Or perhaps you continue to see yourself through the lens of what happened.

This is particularly common when trauma becomes connected to negative beliefs about ourselves.

For example:

  • "I'm not good enough."
  • "I'm powerless."
  • "I'm not safe."
  • "I'm unlovable."
  • "I should have stopped it."
  • "I can't trust myself."

These beliefs can feel incredibly convincing, even when we know logically that they aren't true. Simply telling yourself something different doesn't always change how deeply held these beliefs feel. Sometimes we need to work with the experiences that helped create them in the first place.

‍

Why understanding your trauma doesn't necessarily change how you feel

Imagine you grew up in a home where you never quite knew what mood your parent would be in. Perhaps you learned to watch their face, listen to the tone of their voice and notice the slightest change in their behaviour. You became very good at anticipating what might happen next. You learned to keep the peace, avoid upsetting anyone and make yourself as easy as possible to look after.

Years later, you're an adult. You live independently and your circumstances are completely different. But you still find yourself carefully monitoring other people's moods.

  • If someone sounds a little short with you, you immediately wonder what you've done wrong.
  • If your partner seems quiet, you assume they're upset with you.
  • You find it difficult to say no, worry about disappointing people and feel responsible for keeping everyone happy.
  • You might even recognise that these reactions come from your childhood.

You understand that you were a child trying to manage an unpredictable environment. You know that it wasn't your responsibility to keep your parent happy. You can explain all of this perfectly well. But when someone seems irritated with you, you still feel that familiar knot in your stomach. You still feel the urge to apologise, fix things or make yourself smaller.

You understand that you're no longer that child, but part of you still responds as though you are.

This is one of the ways the effects of childhood trauma can continue into adulthood.

Understanding where these patterns came from is incredibly valuable. But sometimes we also need to work with the memories and experiences that helped create them in the first place.

This is because trauma doesn't just affect our thoughts. It can also affect our emotional and physical responses to reminders of what happened. Understanding why you react in a particular way is important. But sometimes we also need to help the brain process the original experience so that it no longer triggers the same level of distress.

‍

What is EMDR and how is it different?

EMDR stands for Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing. Unlike traditional talking therapy, EMDR doesn't rely on talking through an experience repeatedly in order to process it.

Instead, it involves recalling aspects of a distressing memory while engaging in bilateral stimulation, usually guided eye movements, although other forms of stimulation can be used.

he aim is to help the brain process the memory so that it becomes less distressing. This doesn't mean forgetting what happened. It doesn't mean pretending it wasn't important. And it certainly doesn't mean convincing yourself that something frightening was okay. Instead, the aim is for the memory to become something you can remember without experiencing the same overwhelming emotional and physical reactions.

For example, someone who has experienced a traumatic birth might eventually be able to think about their delivery without feeling the same panic, helplessness or fear. Someone who has experienced childhood trauma might be able to remember what happened without automatically feeling the same shame or believing that they were somehow to blame.

The experience remains part of their history, but it no longer has the same hold over their present.

‍

Does this mean I need to stop talking about my trauma?

Absolutely not.

EMDR isn't about avoiding talking or rushing straight into processing painful memories. Good trauma therapy involves understanding the person, their experiences and what they need from treatment. Before beginning EMDR processing, time is spent exploring your history, identifying what you would like to work on and making sure you have the support and resources needed to approach the memories safely.

Preparation is an important part of EMDR.

Sometimes talking is exactly what is needed. Sometimes EMDR is appropriate. And sometimes a combination of approaches is most helpful. There isn't one approach that works for everyone.

‍

What if I've already had years of therapy?

If you've spent years in therapy, you might feel frustrated at the thought of starting again. Perhaps you've worked incredibly hard to understand yourself and make changes. You might even feel that you've exhausted every possible avenue.

You might have developed a really good understanding of your experiences but not yet had the opportunity to process some of the memories that continue to cause distress. Equally, there may be other things contributing to your difficulties that need attention.

One of the things I find particularly important when working with people who have experienced trauma is helping them recognise that their past doesn't have to keep determining how they feel in the present.

‍

How can EMDR therapy help in Hertford?

I'm a Clinical Psychologist and accredited EMDR Therapist based in Hertford, Hertfordshire.

I work with adults experiencing a range of difficulties relating to trauma, including PTSD, complex trauma, birth trauma, medical trauma and distressing life experiences. If you've previously had therapy but still feel affected by things that happened in the past, it might be worth exploring whether EMDR could be helpful.

You don't need to know exactly what needs processing or even whether EMDR is the right approach. That's something we can explore together. So get in touch to book an appoinment.

‍

Back to blog posts